Microsoft is accusing Comet of mass software piracy. The Windows-wrangler has kicked off a legal battle claiming the British retailer made and sold 94,000 fake Windows recovery discs.
Microsoft says Comet created the counterfeit copies of Windows and sold them to customers buying computers with Windows Vista and Windows XP installed. And we thought 2011 had thrown up some bonkers news stories!
Comet, which is being sold for £2 by French owner Kesa, is accused of making the discs somewhere, somewhere in a factory in Hampshire. Comet says it was providing the discs to customers because Microsoft had stopped supplying recovery discs with Windows computers -- and reckons that's no different to customers making their own backup discs.
Microsoft is notoriously bereft of a sense of humour when it comes to the authenticity of Windows. The software giant's brief said, "Comet produced and sold thousands of counterfeit Windows CDs to unsuspecting customers in the United Kingdom. Comet's actions were unfair to customers. We expect better from retailers of Microsoft products -- and our customers deserve better, too."
Comet counters it "firmly believes that it acted in the very best interests of its customers. It believes its customers had been adversely affected by the decision to stop supplying recovery discs with each new Microsoft Operating System based computer. Accordingly Comet is satisfied that it has a good defence to the claim and will defend its position vigorously."
Comet assures customers that recovery discs will continue to work, although Microsoft directs you to its software-checking site howtotell.com to see if you have a genuine copy of Windows.
Have you bought a Comet computer with a dodgy disc? Is Comet correct, or is it taking the mickey out of Microsoft? Counterfeit a comment or fake it on our Facebook page.

Comments 7
Add your comment
anonymous 4 January, 2012 17:59
As long as Comet supplied valid licences for each machine they sold, I don't see how Microsoft will get very far with this. They wouldn't have lost any money (once you have a legit licenced copy of Windows you can make the recovery disc for free) and Comet wouldn't have profited from this since the licences were already paid for...
anonymous 4 January, 2012 18:44
The disks work on any PC, not just the one purchased for, with no need for product key as they are pre activated. MS is in the right for once
liamdaly 4 January, 2012 18:54
Comet don't seem to be having much recently...
liamdaly 4 January, 2012 18:54
much luck*
anonymous 4 January, 2012 20:56
All comet has to do is get the salesmen to push apple heavily for one month and keep stocks of PCs low. The manufacturers will call Microsoft, Micsrosoft will cal Comet and it will all be forgotten. Sainsburys did something similar to Coke back in the mid nineties and it worked. Not a big Apple or Microsoft fan but it's good to keep all the big boys in line or they will forget the customer if they were allowed to.
anonymous 5 January, 2012 07:58
Sadly with the position comet and all retailers are in no one can afford to do what anonymous is suggesting and the fact is what Comet likely did is create discs in a factory not create them using the partition on the drive which is software piracy.
anonymous 7 January, 2012 17:37
"The disks work on any PC, not just the one purchased for, with no need for product key as they are pre activated. MS is in the right for once"
I would find that hard to belive, most restore dvds are machine specific re drivers and in fact most (if not all) are bios locked as well.
Microsoft is just being Microsoft..............
At £15 per DVD comet would have been making VERY little on these once they paid VAT, TAX, manufacturing costs, staff time etc
Anyways I dont have these problems.....I use linux