This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Samsung Galaxy S2 vs Samsung Galaxy Note vs Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Samsung's built some incredibly good mobiles recently, making its Galaxy range of smart phones a massive player in the tech world. But of the Samsung Galaxy S2, the Samsung Galaxy Nexus and the Samsung Galaxy Note, which Galaxy is deserving of your cash? Let's meet the mobiles that will be vying for our adoration.

Update: We've updated this article now that the Galaxy Nexus' volume bug has been fixed.

Samsung Galaxy S2

The Samsung Galaxy S2 is an absolute beast, and when it came out earlier this year it proved itself to be the best Android phone in the universe. While other phones have grown bigger since, at the time we were blown away by the 4.3-inch Super AMOLED Plus display, and dazzled by its 1.2GHz dual-core processor. But that was months ago! Does the S2 still look so fresh today?

Samsung Galaxy Note

On the off-chance you didn't think the Galaxy S2 was big enough, the Note will certainly sort you out. The display on this monster mobile measures a mammoth 5.3 inches, and it's something of an animal on the inside too, with a 1.4GHz dual-core processor running the show.

Samsung Galaxy Nexus

The Samsung Galaxy Nexus has a 1.2GHz dual-core processor and a 5-megapixel camera, alongside a 4.65-inch display. That's fine, but what really sets this phone apart is that it's running Android 4.0, aka Ice Cream Sandwich, the newest version of Android. Does that make it worth picking up?

Design

The Galaxy Nexus boasts a rounded display, adorned with black gloss and kept looking minimal by a lack of physical buttons. Instead you control the Nexus using three on-screen buttons. It's reasonably slim at 8.9mm thick and it's impressively light at 135g, but we're not blown away by the back plate, which is grey with a textured finished. The bulging spot where the camera pokes out is a little funny-looking too.

The Note is a tad classier, with a curved back and a camera that's flush to the casing. It's 9.7mm slim and 178g, which makes it portable on paper, but you'll likely struggle to fit the Note in your hands, let alone your pocket. There's a serious design no-no going on here too -- Samsung's hidden a cheeky stylus in the bottom of the Note, which is useful for jotting down notes or sketching bowls of fruit, but will almost certainly get lost.

The Samsung Galaxy S2 looks as good as it did when we first snatched it out of its box earlier in the year. It's under 9mm thin and weighs 115g, making it lighter than its Galaxy rivals. The 4.3-inch screen still makes a striking impression, and while some have complained that the case feels rather plasticky, we think the phone itself feels sturdy. It looks and feels fantastic -- we're throwing this one the S2's way.

Design winner: Samsung Galaxy S2

Hardware

The Galaxy S2 blew our tiny minds when it first arrived on the scene, thanks to a dual-core 1.2GHz processor that proved brilliant for apps, games and playing video. The screen was similarly amazing, liquifying our ocular bulbs with the brightness pumped out by its 4.3-inch Super Amoled Plus display.

Almost impossibly, Samsung also squeezed an 8-megapixel camera into the S2's slender chassis, making it an all-around hardware powerhouse.

For a month or so, anyway -- then other smart phones equalled the S2's hardware chops. The Galaxy Nexus goes further than the S2, with a 4.65-inch display that as well as being bigger, boasts a stonkingly high 1,280x720 pixel resolution.

Everything on this panel comes out looking crystal clear, so get ready to be impressed when you fire up a video or web page, and a 1.2GHz dual-core processor keeps everything running smoothly.

But the Galaxy Nexus has a slight hardware downside -- its camera has a meagre 5-megapixel resolution. We were impressed by the stills and video it managed to produce though, so it's not worth writing the Nexus off completely on that front. The Nexus has a 16GB capacity, and you can't expand that using a microSD card.

The Galaxy Note is an absolute hardware monster. Around the back you'll find an 8-megapixel camera, and underneath the bonnet hums an alarmingly potent 1.4GHz dual-core processor that outpaced the Galaxy S2 in our benchmark tests. Using the phone is like sailing through a sea of silk, with apps opening at lightning speed.

The display on offer here is absolutely ginormous at 5.3 inches. In fact, we wouldn't blame you at all if you dismissed the Galaxy Note for being simply too massive. The screen resolution is a touch higher than the Galaxy Nexus' at 1,280x800 pixels, but because the screen is so much bigger it has a lower dpi (dots per inch). It still looks crisp, clear and really colourful though.

Brimming with speedy components and with a screen big enough to eat your dinner off of, the Galaxy Note dominates when it comes to hardware.

Hardware winner: Samsung Galaxy Note

Software

While all three of these phones are running Android, one of them is different. For while the S2 and the Note are powered by version 2.3 of Google's mobile operating system (also known as Gingerbread), the Galaxy Nexus is more advanced, and arrives running Android 4.0, aka Ice Cream Sandwich.

That improved operating system brings visual tweaks, and navigating through the phone is handled by three on-screen buttons, rather than any physical keys. Tapping one of those virtual buttons brings up a new multi-tasking menu, which stacks all the apps you've got running up the screen. Also new are folder refinements, and the ability to unlock your phone with your face.

The other major strength of the Galaxy Nexus is that it's running a vanilla version of Android, whereas the Note and S2 are both running a Samsung-tweaked edition of Android. The benefit of using a version that Samsung hasn't fiddled with is that when updates for Android arrive, you'll get them quicker because you don't have to wait for Samsung to squeeze its custom skin over that new version.

That's not to mention the fact that both the S2 and the Note come with loads of Samsung-installed bloatware apps you almost certainly won't want, and would rather delete as soon as possible.

When it launched, the Nexus was stricken with a bug that caused it to spontaneously drop volume. Happily though, that bug has now been fixed, meaning we're more than chuffed to throw the software prize to the Nexus. It's worth saying though, that this is only a temporary disctinction -- the S2 and Note will soon be updated to ICS.

Software winner: Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Tiebreak

We weren't impressed by the Note's battery life -- that massive screen appears to guzzle juice, and we got less than 12 hours of use from a full charge, even with moderate use. The S2 and Nexus, meanwhile, are decent when it comes to battery life. No smart phone is great when it comes to surviving away from the mains, but based on our tests the S2 and Nexus should both last last you a full day's use.

So the Note is out, leaving just the S2 and the Nexus.

The S2 is a magnificent mobile, but we can't overlook the fact that the Nexus is running a whole new version of Android. So even though the S2 boasts a better design, the Ice Cream-flavoured Nexus is a better blower overall. Congratulations Nexus, you're the best Galaxy phone out there. But will it still be standing tall when the S2 is updated to ICS, or when next year's Galaxy S3 appears?

Overall winner: Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Did we miscalculate? Does another Galaxy phone deserve the crown? Let us know in the comments below, or over on our Facebook wall.

Comments 32

Add your comment

nadz156's avatar

nadz156 24 November, 2011 18:40

Samsung Galaxy S2 (AT&T) running Android 4.0 (ICS)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjwM9aeDN8o&feature=player_embedded

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 November, 2011 19:02

In Software area, Galaxy Note should win, not S2. As note has got extra softwares like SPlanner, SMemo and other facilities.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 November, 2011 22:54

The note has a 5.3' screen not a 5.4'. But does it make a difference,lol.

the note does not support all the apps on the market yet , well not apps but games.

As for the battery life its quite good, lasted atlest for a day.
maybe you guys got a faulty handset.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 04:40

Absolutely..!! Common Guys.. Every other review, I have read, have quoted that Galaxy Note's battery life is among the best. I say that if you can get over the huge size, it is definitely the one to go for.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 05:51

Dumbest comparison ever! There's a reason why sites like engadget have gotten far more popular then cnet.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 06:12

I own a Galaxy S2 a Galaxy Note and I find the battery life of the note is much better than the S2, I am getting between 18 to 20 hours out of it with moderate use. As someone else has suggested maybe you had a faulty handset or battery?

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 06:39

i have a Galaxy s2 and i get 3 days out of it on 1 charge

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 07:34

Iphone wins (cough) LOL

MikeBuck_1's avatar

MikeBuck_1 25 November, 2011 09:17

just a geeky thing, but why have you used a picture of the Note to represent an S2?????

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 11:29

I have the Galaxy Note and I cannot recommend it enough. It's a real winner for Samsung.

Battery life is absolutely fine with the usual 1 charge a day. After owning it for about a month you really don't notice how big it is until someone comments how amazing the phone looks!

Holding it to my ear for calls also does not make me look stupid either (a lot of reviews harp on about this uneccesarily)

I love this phone!

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 16:04

I'm an architect and I wonder if the note be used to take pictures which can be annotated, and drawn over and then downloaded into pc software to produce a specification. That would be great.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 November, 2011 18:54

What's going on with cnet's reviewers these days? This and Jessica Dolcourt 's review of the galaxy nexus (unlocked) makes me sick to death. Please do me a favor. Take a look at the reviews at theVerge, Engadget, etc.
Shame on on you!

doister's avatar

doister 26 November, 2011 07:09

S2 is the best thats fact

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 26 November, 2011 12:04

i have galaxy s2 and this is the best phone in the market.....

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 26 November, 2011 15:36

@MikeBuck_1: What? They're using a picture of the S2 to represent the S2, it's not a picture of the note. That's how the international version (i.e. not the weird carrier-modified US versions, that hate hardware buttons for some reason) looks like.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 26 November, 2011 19:19

galaxy 2 is the best smart phone ever made and all phone have been killed by galaxy s2 so all u idiot stop comparing it
it is best phone

MikeBuck_1's avatar

MikeBuck_1 27 November, 2011 22:35

@Anonymous.. the picture has been changed from the one that was originally put in the article. The original picture had a Note at an angle, this was obvious by the fact that both pics had 5 icons on the bottom line, when the S2 only has 4 (as standard). Maybe CNET can admit this, I won't hold it against them. mistakes happen.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 27 November, 2011 23:35

Why oh why does every site keep on about how stupid you'll look with the Note, how it won't fit in your pocket, how its too big to be useful!?!?! Do you just read other reviews and then try to be a bit more controversial? The physical size of the handset is fine for a phone, but in reality its amazing for tablet. If like me you've spent the past few months trying to decide which handset AND which tablet to get then this is manna from heaven. It has the best hardware specs of ANY handset on the market, including every offering from Android, WP7, IOS, Nokia or BB. Clearly newer handset will arrive shortly with similar benchmarks but right now this is as good as it gets. Having used one and tested it for myself, the size is not a detraction. If someone is going to take the mickey out of you for having a large phone, they probably don't have the IQ to be able to spell NOTE and certainly wouldn't have any need to make use of the unique advantages a seriously big screen brings. I used to have perfect eyesight, now, in my nid 30's its getting worse rapidly, I have to wear glasses about the width of the windscreen on a Boeing airliner. The Note means I don't actually have to have them on to reply to a text message without fear of looking like i'm drunk and its 2am. This is all before it plays its trump card with the stylus, for businesses this could well become the defacto replacement for BlackBerries given the dire offerings from that manufacturer of late. Having used older Windows Mobile era stylus phones I can personally say the game has changed massively. Mine is going to be used for signature capture which in one move will eliminate 90% of all my physical paperwork and mean i have to visit the office much less, and never fear losing a signed document ever again. Having been a HTC regular for many years I'm very glad that Samsung brought this out now, just before I settled and ordered the Sensation XL AND got lumbered with a HTC Flyer. Now I'll have one device that's better at being a phone than any HTC offering and a better tablet than the Flyer ever could dream of being. If you've ever had an Android handset up until now you'll already know how to save battery life with the phones settings, a 2500Ma battery is more than twice the capacity of my current one and when ICS is pushed to the device the life should get even better. So all in all could every reviewer please stop thinking they need to bring up a reference to Dom Jollys sketches or think that potential user wears painted on jeans all day. Can you just review the damn thing on its many merits and understand that if we're looking at a review of the Note we're already not put off by the dimensions.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 30 November, 2011 00:23

well i do not have the note BUT I WILL as soon as i can get my hands on. Regarding the size? The size of the note it is the best size for someone that actually has to WORK and carry it all the time in a pocket or in a briefcase or a folio case; Unfortunately today some buyers of tablets and/or laptop are people that have too SHOW to their friends what "brand" they own, it is a "status" not a necessity, thus, on the market, tablets that weights a million kg and bigger than a laptop !! The size, the weight, the screen, the engine and software of the Note are ideal....games?...people can use a computer at home and use it all night having fun, during the day? lets work a little bit more and produce.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 30 November, 2011 08:19

I have all three and the note is tops. Great battery life

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 1 December, 2011 19:18

The Note and S2 supports 64gb micro sd cards: http://www.infolookout.com/2011/10/64gb-micro-sd-card-works-on-samsung.html

The Nexus doesn't even have a micro sd card slot. Something to think about.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 5 December, 2011 14:12

Among the 3 i think the best is the NOTE. I have the note and the screen is unbelievably great. The colors are sharper because of the hd display. 5.3 is not huge for me anymore. For me there's no wrong about a smartphone being small or huge. It is just that people get used to small phones. When i first saw the note i thought that it was so huge. When i bought it already the same thing but after a week with using it i got used to it and when i hold the iphone or smaller phones it doesnt feel comfortable anymore you're like holding a tiny device. Thumbs up for the NOTE

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 7 December, 2011 15:05

galaxy s2 will be getting the ice cream sandwhich update

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 10 December, 2011 02:58

hello friends! I want to buy a galaxy but not which of the 3 three purchases, please I need help, which is best and why ..... thank you very much, I appreciate your suggestions ..

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 10 December, 2011 03:15

If ONE more reviewer mentions how the note is too big or how stupid you'd look with it next to your ear I would be tempted to assume you are all skinny teenagers who happen to be Justin bieber fans!

Seriously what's WRONG with you guys and then you call yourselves GEEKS!

Geekiness is all about being ahead of the curve, the cutting edge, seeing merit in pushing the envelope. Its not about being some conservative Nancy who thinks that 5 inch screens are too big because err..duh.. "We have never HAD a 5 inch screen". Have any of you guys actually tried spending a month with this thing and realized size really isn't an issue BEFORE reviewing it?

Bottom line: You'll get used to it, just like you got used to colour TV and the internet. Its the future,embrace it, don't fight it and kudos to Samsung for pushing the envelope and flirting with the edge of portability:-)

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 15 December, 2011 18:18

im contemplating the galax ace as its onl 130 and 15 credit on pay as you go a 145 on the three network but how much would the note be on sim free so can still go for the three pay as you go sim ????
can any one help and also is the note still touch screen as thought stlus were the thing of the past lol

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 23 December, 2011 22:13

I have a S2 and i realy like it performance boosts u get from overclocking is awesome so myne can kick the notes ass with speed the notes to big but i realy like it but wont give up my S2 im way to fond of it.galaxy nexus ill rather wait till S2 GETS ICE CREAM SANDWICH

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 December, 2011 10:07

What a stupid result. The S2, despite having a good design, and a good chipset (for media and gaming purposes) loses to the Nexus because it already has ICS preloaded, something the S2 will have soon? The Nexus is the loser, it's inferior compared to the S2 and the Note, it shouldn't even be in the comparison. Call me biased if you like, I'm going for the S2, but the Note is great, I don't care about the size!

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 8 January, 2012 11:25

Bigger resolution means less fps in your game. Galaxy S2 still the fastest AndroidPhone in terms of 3d performance. At least the version powered with Mali-400.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 7 April, 2012 00:31

dears.. can anybody tell that what is best ? galaxy s2 or note?

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 14 April, 2012 07:34

hello everybody.I got my new note few days ago but I have a problem.Unfortunately I downloaded the software of s2 to my note and my note was turned off.please HELP what can I do?

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 9 May, 2012 07:26

hahahahaha....every body is confused....the friends have s2 they like this and friends who owns the note they are happy with this,.if some one want to by including my self,,think in your own mind and buy which is good for you and u like,,,as every body will expend his own mony.i have a iphone4s and its also a nice smart phone...i like this as i have paid the mony.....hahahaha

Post your comment

Make your comment count. Log in or register to skip the 'Are you human?' question and get an avatar

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.