This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Nokia forced to apologise for fake Lumia 920 camera video

Nokia has been forced to apologise after using a 'confusing' promotional video at its New York launch event yesterday, after it emerged that the video purporting to show off its new phone's camera was shot using a dSLR and not the new Lumia 920, as it claimed. 

Nokia chiefs hailed the new Lumia as the "best smart phone to capture pictures on" at their press conference yesterday, bragging about its "floating lens" image stabilisation. This new tech was claimed to best not only their mobile rivals but also some dSLRs. The video demonstration (below), showing a girl being filmed on a bicycle, was used as an example of the steady-eyed device's capabilities.

Keen eyes over at The Verge spotted a reflection, at 0:27, showing it to be shot by a crew in a truck using a professional camera instead of a lad on a bike with the colourful new Windows Phone.

Heidi Lemmetyinen of Nokia issued a public apology: "In an effort to demonstrate the benefits of optical image stabilisation (which eliminates blurry images and improves pictures shot in low light conditions), we produced a video that simulates what we will be able to deliver with OIS.

"Of course, hindsight is 20/20, but we should have posted a disclaimer stating this was a representation of OIS only. This was not shot with a Lumia 920. At least, not yet. We apologise for the confusion we created."

It's possible the phone was unfinished at the time of shooting the promo, which would make the new Lumia's release date of 'later this year' more like 'late this year' at the earliest. But Nokia later released the following, much less glossy, video to demonstrate OIS:

Nokia has already faced criticism about the lack of similarity between the Nokia 808 PureView and its new flagship model, which also dons the PureView mantle. The Symbian-powered 808 boasts an industry topping 41-megapixel sensor, while the 920 only matches the smart phone standard of 8 megapixels. 

Damian Dinning, imaging experience manager at Nokia, defended this decision in a series of tweets earlier this week. He said the PureView label is about "blending optics, pixels and image processing in new and different ways", hinting at the 920's high-end Carl Zeiss lens and image processing algorithms. "It's not about the number of pixels but what you do with them," he added. The rather defensive '#getoverit' hashtag got some fans' backs up, however.

We can't wait to properly review the new Lumia's camera and see these image stabilisation benefits for ourselves. But in the meantime let us know what you think of the phone -- and all this hoo-ha -- down in the comments or on Facebook.

Comments 12

Add your comment

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 6 September, 2012 14:01

Good that they come clean, its not like apple is going to come clean and say look at the new LG retina display in our phone, look how zippy this processor is from the company were sueing, look how good this Sony camera is that we use. We are innovators, biggest piece c@&% I've ever heard in my life, get all these pieces from all these different companies and sell it for probably 3 times as much as they get it for, if not more.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 6 September, 2012 15:19

gotta agree with anonymous. very funny. also let's stop thinking that megapixels are the answer to good pics, steve jobs said this when defending the iphone in the early days. nokia are right, its about light that you can get in the lens. if you go to other sites who are actually at these events you will see comparison pics using the 920 and the low light pictures are awesome. anyone know someone in the UK I can get to take winphone8 off and put jelly bean on for me?? :D
On the whole i'm very impressed with the 920. will have to wait and see if it's too big or not for me.

shauney3's avatar

shauney3 6 September, 2012 15:35

HAHA busted! I'm sure all companies do similar...

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 6 September, 2012 15:44

They're only sorry they got found out.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 6 September, 2012 21:08

This article has quite a few errors, Nokia stated that the footage was shoot using prototype hardware, not a dSLR. Most likley a pre-production prototype using the same technology as the 920. C'mon CNET get your act together! If anyone wants to see how the camera on the 920 is superiour to a 4s and SGS3 then Youtube "Nokia photo contest". It really is an impressive bit of kit. Looking forward to seeing what Apple bring to the party next week.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 7 September, 2012 06:52

I think it was a clever "mistake".

Free publicity! Simple!

Mark Anderson's avatar

Mark Anderson 7 September, 2012 08:05

Quite funny really. Nokia's marketing department have always been shambolic.

Does it matter? Not really. Who buys a smartphone on the basis of a company promo anyway? Other than iPhone users I mean. ;)

Darren Forster's avatar

Darren Forster 7 September, 2012 08:09

What's wrong with this anyway? Companies do these types of tricks all the time. I went to one of the Olympic Flame Festivals and they had Twist and Pulse there taking our pictures on what appeared to be just a Samsung Galaxy phone, and the picture that came from that was simply amazing as you could see me and my friends really clearly even though we were quite far back in a crowd of hundreds - the picture quality must have been at least 40-50mp for that quality, also when we looked at the stage you could see other more professional cameras which were probably the ones that picture came off, not the Samsung Galaxy so that's quite misleading of Samsung too.

So it's not just Nokia who try these tricks, numerous firms do. Food companies make ready made meals look different to the slop you get in the box.

My only issue with Nokia though is why on earth have they gone for Windows Phone??? Why not at least launch one of their phones as Android. I used to like Nokia years ago and even played Nokia Game, but since they've been hanging onto Symbian, a decadent phone OS, and now switching to WP7. I've got a HTC HD2 WM6.5 phone but am looking at upgrading to Android 'cos Android has a lot more going for it, it's far more open, has far more apps, and works far better. Unless Microsoft do something spectacular soon they're going to end up following Nokia into the abyss, left behind by modern technology.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 7 September, 2012 20:07

Nokia have missed the one vital element of a succesful smartphone launch which would have ensured their re-emergence at the forefront of the smartphone market....don't show us a 41 mega-pixel camera technology called pureview and then try to tell its customers to 'getoverit when all they can muster is 8.7 mp with some springs on the lens mount'.
All this nonsense about it not being important how many pixels one has its what you do with the ones you've got that counts sound a bit like what a polite but disappointed lover may say to an under endowed partner so as not to hurt their feelings. The stench of dissappointment is overwhelming....Dear Santa, can I have more mega-pixels please?

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 8 September, 2012 05:25

Goot dum Mr

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 9 September, 2012 19:04

Lets not gloss over the facts, they LIED, pure and simple. I hope this is very damaging to them, to teach them and any other company a lesson.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 11 September, 2012 10:45

Well talking about fake advertisement... take at close look at this Samsung Galaxy Beam video... at 0:30 you will se the Beam project a vidoe onto the cealing of a very well lit room... and that with a pico-projector with 15 Lumen!!! A normal projector has around 2000 Lumen, and everyone knows that the room has to be nearly dark for this to work, so c'on give Nokia a break...
But lately Nokia has become the Prügelknabe for everyone - but that's probably the price for beeing the "biggets" - it's like IBM in the 80's when everyone fell over them - especially Apple (1984 ad) - and behold - what's become of Apple and who is falling all over the others (especially over Samsung lately)

Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCdnBg-r4Gw&feature=relmfu

Post your comment

Make your comment count. Log in or register to skip the 'Are you human?' question and get an avatar

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

Best mobile deals

Nokia Lumia 920 »

Nokia Lumia 920

Phone FREE

£22.00 per month

600 mins

Unlimited texts

750MB data

O2 24 month contract

Nokia Lumia 920

Phone FREE

£27.00 per month

Unlimited mins

Unlimited texts

1GB data

O2 24 month contract

Nokia Lumia 920

Phone FREE

£22.00 per month

600 mins

Unlimited texts

750MB data

O2 24 month contract

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.