If you're looking for a cheaper way to hook up with Windows Phone 8 and its cheery live-tile lifestyle than Nokia's pricey Lumias, HTC is here to help. The HTC 8S -- or Windows Phone 8S by HTC to give its full perfume-inspired name -- is out now for £180 (plus top-up) on pay as you go from Three, and on pre-order from Expansys at £240 SIM-free.
That's at least £150 less than the most comparable Nokia, the £360 Lumia 820. We haven't reviewed the 8S yet, so I can't say exactly how they stack up, but let's have a look at what you get on paper.
The 8S has a slightly smaller screen than the 820 -- 4 inches versus 4.3 inches -- but the resolution is exactly the same, 480x800 pixels. That's not fantastic (the 4.7-inch Nexus 4, only £20 more, has 768x1,280 pixels) but it does mean the 8S has a few more pixels per inch than the 820, so in theory it'll be slightly sharper. The 820 has 217 pixels per inch, whereas the 8S has 233 (the Nexus 4 has a staggering 317).
Leaving the Android-toting Nexus 4 to one side, the 8S lacks Nokia's exclusive apps and services. These are Nokia Drive, a turn-by-turn sat-nav app; Nokia CityLens, which overlays useful local information on your camera display; and Nokia Music, which streams tunes for free. All are well made and valuable, and make up somewhat for the lack of great apps on Windows Marketplace, but none are indispensable.
The real difference between the two phones is invisible: the components inside. The 820 has significantly more powerful chips, such as a 1.5GHz dual-core processor and 1GB of RAM, compared to the 8S's slower 1GHz chip and pathetic 512MB of RAM.
Whether you'll notice any difference is hard to say without using the 8S extensively and running benchmarks. But Windows Phone's transitions -- the animations that move you from one screen to the next -- run at a fixed pace. In theory, you'll only notice performance on games and other testing apps, of which there are few in the Marketplace right now.
Elsewhere, both take microSD cards to expand your storage up to 64GB. The Nokia's 8-megapixel camera trounces the HTC's 5-megapixel effort on paper at least, and I wouldn't be surprised for the difference to be marked in their photos. We found the 820's camera very good for what you're paying.
Compare phones on contract, pay as you go and SIM-free on our mobile deals section -- you'll find the HTC 8S and Nokia Lumia 820 at those links. Which of these Windows Phones floats your boat? Would you take a punt on either of them? Let me know down in the comments, or on our bargain-basement Facebook page.



Comments 11
Add your comment
anonymous 7 December, 2012 12:50
I wouldn't take a punt on either of them, but I would take a s**t on both of them
anonymous 7 December, 2012 13:05
@anonymous 12:50
sigh why does CNET always attract the worst audience.
your remark is neither funny nor useful, get lost.
anonymous 7 December, 2012 13:07
Perhaps there is something like the Nokia 620.
anonymous 7 December, 2012 14:22
I thought it was quite funny, and no I am not a low brow neanderthal who only laughs at poo jokes… all the time ;-D
anonymous 7 December, 2012 14:24
It was about as funny as a turd in a swimming pool...
damien2501 7 December, 2012 14:38
Judging by the intelligence of the people slating windows phones they are probably a good purchase
shauney3 7 December, 2012 14:44
It is about time Windows phones were available for a lower price. The specs seriously lack behind Android phones yet they retail for the same price?.. So £180 sounds like a good deal. I won't be getting one, as Android phones are better, but at least there is some choice and competition out there - loving the bold colours too!
anonymous 7 December, 2012 15:17
Nokia have just announced the 620. Same specs as the 8S, but cheaper still. The 820 is in a different league the 8S.
Jonathan Aze 7 December, 2012 15:38
How is this in any way a fair comparison? apart from the operating system, these phones have nothing in common. The headline 'HTC 8S Windows Phone out now, far cheaper than Nokia 820' is, in android terms, is like have a headline saying 'sony experia tipo (insert any other woeful cheap droid here if you want) out now, much cheaper than the samsung galaxy S3'
anonymous 10 December, 2012 21:48
Cheaper than the 820?
There is no need for this article. The two can't be compared. Completely different specs.
Were the htc 8s to have a competitor in the nokia range, it would probably be the follow up to the lumia 710.
Jason Alexander 11 December, 2012 17:46
Such a shame the Lumia doesn't look this good.