This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

Which iPad should I buy: New iPad or iPad mini?

As the new iPad mini and souped-up iPad burst onto the scene, which iPad is right for you: full-size or fun-size? Stick with us, kid, and we'll talk you through the options -- including bagging a rare bargain from Apple.

The main difference between the two types of Apple tablets is the size. The new fourth generation of the traditional large iPad boasts a 9.7-inch display, which means it has plenty of room on the screen for watching movies, playing games and browsing the Web.

Meanwhile, the new iPad mini has less space on its 7.9-inch screen, but is more portable. It's not a trouser-pocket proposition, but at 7.2mm thick it's so slim it will fit in a handbag, larger jacket pocket, or even a back pocket if you remember not to sit down.

There's more to screens than size, however. The full-sized iPad has what Apple calls a retina display, which means it has an eye-popping level of detail. The iPad mini doesn't have a retina display, presumably to keep the cost down. Instead, the resolution is 1,024x768-pixels, which equals a middling 168ppi -- not a patch on the full-sized model's 264ppi.

The iPad mini's screen is roughly as detailed as the older iPad 2, and it also has the same dual-core A5 processor inside. The full-sized new iPad has a much faster A6X chip and quad-core graphics, so is likely to be super-responsive at browsing, burning through apps and playing games. But the iPad 2 was far from sluggish, and a less powerful chip uses less battery juice. We reckon you'd only notice a significant difference between the two with really complex tasks such as video editing on your tablet.

Both new iPads have 4G gubbins built-in, so you use them on the UK's first 4G network, which is launched by EE next week.

They also both have the same Lightning dock connector, 5-megapixel camera with 1080p video, and the same iOS software and apps built-in. One difference is that the iPad mini takes tiny nano-SIM cards, while the fourth-generation iPad sticks with the marginally larger micro-SIM.

Conclusion

The iPad is roomier and more powerful, but the iPad mini is more portable and still beefy enough for everyday tasks. Ultimately then, the deciding features are size and price.

The 16GB iPad mini starts at £269, a full £130 cheaper than the £399 required for the 16GB fourth-generation iPad. 3G adds £100 to both tablets, so the 3G mini starts at £369 and the iPad starts at £499.

And the budget option? Apple has got rid of all previous versions of the iPad, even though the most recent third-generation model is barely seven months old. Fortunately that means refurbished models of that third-generation iPad are available for a mere £315, complete with retina display and old-style dock connector.

What's the alternative?

You don't need to get an iPad at all, of course: the Google Nexus 7 and Kindle Fire HD are substantially cheaper than the iPad mini -- click here for our head-to-head battle between the iPad mini and its Android rivals.

Meanwhile the full-sized iPad is challenged by the likes of the Asus Transformer Prime and the Microsoft Surface.

Which is the iPad for you -- or are they all a waste of money? Tell me which you think is the best tablet in the comments or on our Facebook page.

Comments 17

Add your comment

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 15:50

iPad 2 is the best tablet I knew until I saw iPad mini. iPad mini is promising, reasonable and I know it will do everything that any other iPad does with much portability and style. Nexus and kindle are very alien for me, I never used android tablet just becoz of coolness factor. I love silver and white shades more. And I prefer glass and aluminium to plastic.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 16:04

^Obviously trying to provoke. Sick and tired of such people.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 16:07

The main comparison Apple kept making in their keynote is that it has a bigger screen then the Nexus. That says it all really. It's old hat; an old hat OS, old hat chip, old hat 4:3 screen...load of rubbish. Yeah, great, it's 0.9 inches bigger than a Nexus. It's also slower, more expensive, less portable, much lower resolution and it has really limited stone age software. Move on. This is for the luddites of 2012.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 16:09

You should get Nexus 7 people!
Waste of hard earned money here

liam_omuk's avatar

liam_omuk 24 October, 2012 16:33

Has no one else noticed, in their keynote apple said the iPad mini is better than nexus because nexus has 16:9 screen - so why have they just changed the iPhone and iPod around to a aspect ratio they feel is sub-standard?

Ichi_Bear 's avatar

Ichi_Bear 24 October, 2012 16:37

Not really much of a comparison. Why not show the iPad Mini side by side with it's competitors. With price and specs so that people can make an informed choice. There are alternatives which are just as easy to use and that offer much better value for money. I'm really getting bored with tech sites hyping up Apple and not giving a balanced objective review of available technology. :-\

Rob Berry's avatar

Rob Berry 24 October, 2012 17:11

If you can't hack an extra £60/70 for a tablet you really shouldn't be looking for one...

The OS is not old hat iOS6 is sightly buggy but still a great OS to use especially for kids. it doesn't feature a quad-core like the nexus but even the nexus doesn't need a quad-core. I expect the iPad mini will have an edge in battery life on comparison which I would happily sacrifice some unnecessary processing power for some more battery. It's not always so much about all the hardware but how it all fits together. In my opinion it looks like a real contender in the budget-tablet market, And I think it will be very popular indeed.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 18:07

Hell. I'm driving myself crazy. I really need a tablet because I'm currentlyusing a 10 year old mac. I'm used to macs and love them for their beauty and ease of use and clever little extras but am more than willing to go elsewhere if it's worth it. I simply do not know whether to buy a new Samsung galaxy Tab 16gb for £399; a refurbished ipad3 gb for £369 or a ipad mini gb for £326. Does anyone have any advice?

I'd be madly grateful.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 22:22

Personally I would go for the Mini, personally I do not like Android, and Samsung should stick to making TV's(their good at that) plus the extra cost for hardly noticeable performance justifies the Mini. Plus the compact size makes it easier to carry as it can fit in most large pockets.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 23:23

So youwould pay 100£ more to surf half of the web and Facebook ? Ok.....

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 24 October, 2012 23:40

I've been holding off buying an iPad for a while, but recently decided to go ahead and buy one.
When rumours and news of the Mini coming out started to circulate I thought I'd wait and see what was happening and I'm now glad I did.

Hopefully the iPad 4 will be mine in a few weeks time, but I'm also thinking of buying a Mini as well. The reasoning is that I won't be able to get my hands on it, with Wife and teenage kids wanting to use it too. Hopefully having two of these devices will mean I can actually get to use them now and then.

Rich Trenholm's avatar

Rich Trenholm 25 October, 2012 00:17

Ichi the Bear - we've just done that here

http://crave.cnet.co.uk/laptops/ipad-mini-vs-google-nexus-7-vs-amazon-kindle-fire-hd-50009577/

This is a comparison of the new iPads, and if you check out the link you'll see a comparison of the iPad versus other tablet such as the Google Nexus 7. Enjoy!

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 October, 2012 05:45

I like NEW IPAD 3 because of its size and improved retina display quality.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 October, 2012 05:47

I like NEW IPAD 3 because of its size, features,and improved quality of retina display..

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 26 October, 2012 07:49

There's nothing "old hat" or out of date with this new Mini iPad.
The iPad 2 that the processor comes from, still rocks and its screen still looks great, despite being bettered by the Retina screen models.
It is going to sell like hot cakes and I wouldn't be surprised if they'll struggle to get enough stock into the shops to satisfy demand this Christmas.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 29 October, 2012 09:10

Early stocks of the mini are sold out already. A two week wait for delivery which will probably get longer once it's in the shops and people get to see it in the flesh.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 19 April, 2013 10:09

I think your use of the iPad has a huge effect on which model you should get. As web designers we have the old iPad 3, which gives us something very portable but with a substantial screen resolution.
We've utilised this not just for meetings be to showcase some of our responsive designs at trade shows and B2B Exhibitions, great attention grabber on a iPad display stand . So for us it needed to be portable, but not too small!
Though I can't pretend we're not tempted by the mini too

Post your comment

Make your comment count. Log in or register to skip the 'Are you human?' question and get an avatar

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.