This web site uses cookies to improve your experience. By viewing our content, you are accepting the use of cookies. To find out more and change your cookie settings, please view our cookie policy. Close

You're wasting your money on Sky and Virgin, Freeview says

You're wasting your money paying for telly -- because the best shows are free. That's according to Freeview, the free TV service, which I caught up with to talk about YouView, 4G breaking your telly, and why you're paying £200 a year too much for Sky and Virgin Media.

As technology fans, we're usually concerned with the early adopters, the cutting edge, the latest thing. HD, 3D and 4K; smart TVs, online streaming and second-screen iPad apps. But Freeview isn't interested in all that: Freeview is for the majority of viewers who just plain old-fashioned watch telly.

Freeview suggests linear TV -- watching a show when it's on -- is enormously resilient, even in our age of catch-up this and streaming t'other. In fact, Freeview reckons only 1 per cent of the Olympics was watched online.

Freeview also reckons the humble aerial will survive into the next decade -- and perhaps even into the 2030s too.

YouView 

In fact, the free TV service is so happy that aerials are sticking around, it's not bothered by YouView, the next generation of free telly that pipes live shows and catch-up into your TV via the Web. YouView boxes are given away with broadband contracts by Internet service providers, a relationship that seems more future-proof than relying on aerials to always be around. 

Mass audience

19.3m homes have the necessary kit to watch Freeview -- a TV with a Freeview tuner and an aerial -- of which 10.6m use Freeview for their main telly watching.

Showing how Freeview isn't necessarily for the early adopters or those who splash the cash on their AV setup, just 3 million people are equipped to watch the current Freeview HD lineup. As BBC2 takes the number of free HD channels to four, there are plans for another six next year.

You're wasting your money

Freeview reckons Sky, Virgin Media and the rest are a waste of cash for most people. 95 per cent of the UK's most-watched programmes are on channels you can see on Freeview. That's from a list of the top 1,000 shows from the first half of last year -- not counting one-offs like the Jubilee -- including Fresh MeatMasterchef and Big Brother.

That's an eye-opening figure, although it's a bit circular: the most widely available shows are the most widely viewed, perhaps because they're the most widely available.

Freeview has done research into the habits of pay TV customers, and found that only 25 per cent of the telly watched by average customers (not including subscribers to Sky Sports or Sky Movies) is on paid channels. In fact, Freeview has mathematised the amount spent on pay TV compared to the amount of time spend watching channels to figure out we're wasting £200 a year on channels we're not watching.

Of course, the question is whether that small percentage of shows only available from pay TV -- like Game of Thrones and Mad Men, not to mention movies and sports -- are worth enough to you to pay for the whole shebang. 

4G filter-fitters

When super-fast LTE data for mobile phones arrives this year, those 4G signals will interfere with some Freeview TVs. Freeview's reaction boils down to 'not our problem'. It will keep a close eye on the DMSL, the industry body that will provide 4G filters to affected households to fix the problem, but has no plans to get involved or to tell viewers about the issue. 

Is Freeview being short-sighted by not embracing the Internet, or is the humble aerial here to stay? Are Sky and Virgin Media worth the money, or is Freeview better value? And how do you watch telly these days? Tell me your thoughts in the comments or on our Facebook page.

Comments 28

Add your comment

Damien2501's avatar

Damien2501 20 February, 2013 01:51

It's really down to who you are and whether you need Sky or not. We recently got Sky TV & Sky Sports and Sky certainly do have a lot of content, and going through their website they are quite expensive but from what I've read they are very easy to negotiate with after your with them a for while. Sky feature highly ranked on polls about haggling so it may seem expensive at first but eventually the price will come down for customers.

Damien2701's avatar

Damien2701 20 February, 2013 07:24

I recently had to cut back a little and sky was the first thing to go. I aint really missed it tbh. Freeview has some great shows and my tv has freeview HD built in which is a bonus. Its not that sky is bad or anything its just not worth £55 for sky with sky sports, in my opinion

Patrick Cantellow's avatar

Patrick Cantellow 20 February, 2013 07:46

We used to have free view and it was great, we used iplayer and things like that. But when we moved, only 1 mile away the signal was broken by loads of trees and the ariel company done a scan and they said "excess signals" are also adding to the problem. So we just went with TiVo and it is so much better, with everything on it. People on Freeview don't know what there missing. (Even if it is VERY expensive)

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 09:11

What a load of bullsh17 - its 2013 and theres STILL only 4 HD channels on Freeview

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 09:22

What about the SKYs comprehensive HD service & excellent planner recorder system.

And the magic eye link as well of course which enabled me to route SKY to 4 tvs in the house all with their own remote control.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 09:22

What about the SKYs comprehensive HD service & excellent planner recorder system.

And the magic eye link as well of course which enabled me to route SKY to 4 tvs in the house all with their own remote control.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 09:23

What about the SKYs comprehensive HD service & excellent planner recorder system.

And the magic eye link as well of course which enabled me to route SKY to 4 tvs in the house all with their own remote control.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 09:24

What about the SKYs comprehensive HD service & excellent planner recorder system.

And the magic eye link as well of course which enabled me to route SKY to 4 tvs in the house all with their own remote control.

jaym's avatar

jaym 20 February, 2013 09:28

My favourite line: "found that only 25 per cent of the telly watched by average customers (not including subscribers to Sky Sports or Sky Movies) is on paid channels"

That is like saying if we exclude one of the main reasons people pay for sky we find they only spend 25% of their time watching sky. Totally illogical argument

Rich Trenholm's avatar

Rich Trenholm 20 February, 2013 09:36

You're absolutely right, Jaym. The point is though if you're not bothered about sports and movies, why are you paying for Sky?

Matt Winston.'s avatar

Matt Winston. 20 February, 2013 10:11

I've been with Sky on and off since 2001. Having the full package is ideal for families because of their content. I've currently got 50% off Sky Sports because I got a special code from MoneySavingExpert.

Peter Hudson's avatar

Peter Hudson 20 February, 2013 10:30

But on Sky you have CBS Reality and CBS Drama so on the weekends I can watch Judge Judy from 10am through until 9pm.

If that's not a good reason to pay for Sky, I don't know what is.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 10:40

To be fair, people (like me) pay extra for Sky+ so that you can pause, rewind, and record TV. I've not checked prices lately but last I did check it would set you back a couple of hundred pounds to get those facilities with Freeview.

Sky One, Sky Atlantic, and Fox are well worth paying a bit extra for.

I don't know what Rich's point is. Sky has a LOT more to offer than Movies and Sports, even with a basic package (see the three channels I named for a start, then consider Comedy Central, SyFy, and Sky Box Office).

Oh, and you also get a fairly comprehensive catch up service too, meaning you can watch iPlayer etc. through your TV without buying anything extra.

Matt Winston.'s avatar

Matt Winston. 20 February, 2013 10:42

^ Get a life Peter...Those 2 channels are free though, if you don't subscribe to Sky you can still use your Sky Box to watch free-view channels and lots of free satellite channels, including CBS.

Matt Winston.'s avatar

Matt Winston. 20 February, 2013 10:44

@anonymous 20 February, 2013 10:40 Sorry, that arrow was at Peter and I agree with you.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 13:15

Sky sports or bust for me. end of.

NJZ tech's avatar

NJZ tech 20 February, 2013 13:51

I think yh freeview is good and betterr value but if you really feel that you need a couple of extra channels (for example sky channels) then be my guest; If you have the money then yh tivo is great and so are services from sky too!

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 13:53

Sky Atlantic, FOX and Sky Sports F1 are the reason for me to go with Sky, all in glorious HD as well.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 20 February, 2013 18:33

How many f*%&ing four digit Damiens are there and does anybody care what they have to say?

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 21 February, 2013 11:42

What a load of rubbish, freeview don't know what they are talking about! Yes freeview is cheaper, but they don't have the channels, features, and programmes that Sky and Virgin do. I'm with Virgin and I watch loads of channels which freeview simply don't have. Where on freeview is GOLD, Watch, National Geographic, FOX, Sky 1, Discovery?? Unless freeview add all the channels that are on Virgin and Sky, then I'm staying with Virgin.

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 21 February, 2013 20:54

One acronym: HTPC.

I've got a Windows 8 box w/ Media Center and the Netflix app as well as an auto VPN and a Hulu Plus subscription. for £11 a month, I get freeview HD with all of the fancy rewind and record stuff, as well as all of the catch up services through TunerFreeMCE (for free) and all the HD I can eat from Netflix and Hulu Plus-- including most of those fancy shows on Sky (and a couple days or weeks earlier than Sky...)

redmozzy's avatar

redmozzy 22 February, 2013 13:33

I have sky but admit its really only for Formula 1, its the only thing I watch religiously and it was either move to sky or only get half the races live and in full. Having said that, I do watch channels not available on free services but because I have them, I wouldn't miss them if I didn't have them.

One I totally disagree with free view over is on demand tv. I very rarely watch live TV these days unless I'm mindless channel hopping. For programmes I actually want to watch, its either recorded or streamed (apart from the F1 of course)

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 22 February, 2013 14:35

Sky One is getting stronger all the time. Sky Atlantic has BRILLIANT shows and Sky Living is pretty good as well. I do think it is over priced and Freeview in our area is still patchy.

mynamesleon's avatar

mynamesleon 22 February, 2013 16:00

I think it kind of depends on who you're targeting. As much as I love technology, live streaming, etc. I live in a village in the countryside. I can barely use skype and watch a youtube video at the same time during off-peak times, let alone peak! If you live in a city, or even a large town, then sure, services like netflix etc. make sense. But until broadband in this country actually reaches decent speeds throughout the countryside, there will be a strong audience for good old fashioned TV

WillieB's avatar

WillieB 22 February, 2013 16:47

Buy a BT Vision Box

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 23 February, 2013 02:42

freeview get comedy central, sky 1 and some mtv channels then we can talk about this serious until then, leave it yeah. must admit thought its great for my bedroom, just not up to front room needs

anonymous's avatar

anonymous 25 February, 2013 12:58

'HMV' springs to mind when i read this article regarding not embracing the internet.

roblightbody's avatar

roblightbody 26 February, 2013 13:51

Freeview and a good recorder are the perfect combination for most people. I use windows media center with a dedicated 2TB hard drive. (tv tuner + hard drive + xbox extender). In general, its superb.

I can't bear to watch streaming internet television, especially commercial stuff, because there is no way to skip past the adverts. With my recorded freeview programs, I save myself hours of my life by zooming past all the adverts.

Post your comment

Make your comment count. Log in or register to skip the 'Are you human?' question and get an avatar

Your email will not be displayed with your comment

Copy the letters and numbers to prove that you're human. You won't have to do this if you log in or register

Your comment must comply with the Terms of Use

About CBS Interactive

Copyright © 2013 CBS Interactive Limited. All rights reserved.