HD DVD is dead. Really, they've checked its pulse this time
Tags: toshiba, discs, switch, dvds
Psychic powers weren't required to have seen this coming -- although it was rather sooner than expected -- but today Toshiba announced that it would no longer be supporting its own format, HD DVD. Blu-ray is officially triumphant and tech journalists worldwide now have one less thing to write about.
Although the format war is over and we can all buy into hi-def content with an easy mind, the death of a rival to Blu-ray should be mourned, for several reasons. There's now no incentive for Blu-ray player makers to reduce their hardware prices. There's no competition now, and that means there will be no massive price battles at strategic holiday periods any more. Say goodbye to those increasingly ridiculous 'seven free disc' offers that were all over the place before Christmas.
We can also say goodbye to the combo disc, the HD DVD with a DVD included, that could play on either machine. This was handy for those with lots of DVDs or people who were waiting before buying an HD DVD player, but wanted to have discs to play when they made the switch. Needless to say, Blu-ray doesn't offer such a friendly option.
It's also time to welcome back that consumer favourite, the region code. HD DVD had the decency to dispense with the stupidity that was regional locking. Blu-ray, on the other hand, isn't so forward-looking. Although many distributors opt not to add a region code, there is no guarantee this will last.
Sadly we'll also be cursed with a lifetime of bad spelling. HD DVD is simple -- people sometimes inserted an errant hyphen, but that was nothing compared to the possible errors with the Blu-ray name. Here are some of the many mis-spellings we've seen: Blue ray, Blue-ray, Blurray, Blurry and Blu-Ray.
Of course, if you were an early adopter, you'll almost certainly have some HD DVDs that you've purchased over the last year. Don't worry too much, they'll continue to play and your HD DVD player won't suddenly explode. With luck, you'll have a good few years left in your HD collection before you have to replace any of the discs. That said, we think the movie studios should offer to replace all HD DVDs with Blu-ray versions for people who want to switch over.
Rest in peace HD DVD, you will be missed. –Ian Morris
RELATED LINKS
RELATED REVIEWS
SnowdonTue 19 February, 2008 5:04pm
RIP HD-DVD 2006-2008
CartmanFri 22 February, 2008 2:47pm
RIP indeed - They should make it legal to RIP your HDDVD discs onto Blu-ray. Finally get Transformers and the Matrix onto Blu-ray...
I got a blu-ray drive on my laptop which I use to play my movies and burn blu-ray discs but the discs are so expensive that It's cheaper to buy a HD DVD player with 7 movies than to a pack of 10 blank Blu-ray discs! - Shocking!
AnonymousFri 22 February, 2008 3:25pm
I totally agree with Cartman.
I think Toshiba have chickened out too early. What does it mean for other manufacturers. I mean does this mean no more HD DVDs will be created on the market???
Why couldn't fim studios record movies on both versions? I mean in some parts of the world movies are still available as vcds and dvds. So whats the issue with one format? Like there's one format of memory cards, one type of battery, one type of screen technology, one type of processor... Ok I think you get my point here!!! :)
AnonymousFri 22 February, 2008 4:04pm
Does anyone know what this means for HD games.
Is my Xbox 360 elite also going to be forced into early retirement?
AnonymousFri 22 February, 2008 6:56pm
the xbox 360 doesn't use HD media fo their games. They all come on standard DVDs. The Elite only has HD DVD capability if you have the seperate HD DVD drive.
AnonymousSun 24 February, 2008 12:36pm
I bet that graphic was for if HD-DVD won and you really wanted to use it!
Ian MorrisTue 26 February, 2008 12:39pm
Yeah, I'll admit, I made it a while ago, but never got a chance to use it. It was now or never ;)

Ask questions, share opinions and find answers in the CNET.co.uk forums



AnonymousTue 19 February, 2008 4:54pm
Freakin, FINALLY!!!!!
One more thing to say though,
BOOM!
Mwa ha ha ha ha ha ha ha haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!